Good Versus Good
by Randy Ingermanson
Advanced Fiction Writing
Many stories have as their main plot a conflict between âthe good guysâ and âthe bad guys.â
You can think of any number of examples. The Harry Potter series. The Hunger Games series. Just about any mystery or suspense novel. And on and on.
âGood guysâ against âbad
guysâ makes a good story, no doubt about it. But thereâs a way to make
it better without much effort. Throw in a bit of dissension among the
good guys.
So a secondary plot of the story is âgood guysâ against the other âgood guys.â
This makes your story stronger for a couple of reasons:
- Now your âgood guysâ have an even tougher problem. They not only
have to defeat the âbad guys,â but theyâve first got to also settle the
differences among themselves.
- It introduces the possibility of a genuine moral dilemma in your
story. Because the competing groups of âgood guysâ may have different
values that drive them. And now you have to wrestle with which of those
competing values is most important.
Just as an example, consider the case of the Harry Potter series. This is definitely a âgood guysâ versus âbad guysâ series.
The âbad guysâ are Lord Voldemort and his gang of thugs who want to take over the world and oppress the Muggles.
The âgood guysâ are the decent witches and wizards who want to leave the Muggles alone.
In book 1 of the series,
our hero, Harry Potter, goes off to school at Hogwarts and begins to
learn about the magical world he belongs to.
Harry has no idea about
the massive battle looming with Voldemort and his minions. Instead, heâs
surrounded on all sides by different factions of âgood guys.â
For starters, there are
four competing houses within the school. Three of these are âgood
guysââHarryâs own Gryffindor, along with Ravenclaw and Hufflepuff.
Harry quickly becomes best
friends with Ron Weasley, another first-year student, whoâs a bit of a
goof-off. Ron and Harry find themselves at odds with another first-year,
Hermione Granger, who comes off as a stuck-up know-it-all. Eventually,
the three become friends, but it takes a troll to bring them together.
There are many cliques within Gryffindor. There are the cool kids, Fred and George Weasley and their friend Lee Jordan.
Then there is Neville Longbottom, nerdy and klutzy and generally a bit weird.
Ron and Fred and George
have an unbearably prissy older brother named Percy, who happens to be
the prefect of Gryffindor this year, and who makes life miserable for
his brothers.
Not to mention Ron
Weasleyâs very cool older brothers, Bill and Charlie, whoâve already
graduated and left behind excellent reputations that Ron canât hope to
match.
Then thereâs Oliver Wood,
captain of the Quidditch team, who really gets upset when Harry gets
himself in trouble and canât perform up to snuff on the Quidditch field.
And letâs not forget Hagrid, the affable half-giant who loves strange creatures and is secretly raising a baby dragon.
There are a lot of âgood guysâ here, all competing in different ways. They donât mean to be making the battle againt the âbad guysâ harder.
But thatâs exactly what theyâre doing.
Near the end of the story,
Harry and Hermione sneak out one night to help Hagrid get rid of a baby
dragon thatâs getting much too big to hide any longer. They succeed in
getting the dragon safely rehomedâbut then get caught before they can
sneak back in to Gryffindor. And caught with them is the bumbling
Neville, who sneaked out to try to find them and warn them to get back
where they belong. This gets them detention and causes Gryffindor to
lose 150 points.
As a result, Harry and
Hermione feel the rage of the entire Gryffindor student body. Theyâre
instant pariahs and the whole house treats them with contempt for weeks.
As final exams loom, Harry
and Ron and Hermione learn that Lord Voldemort is about to do something
terrible. Theyâve got to stop him, so they decide to sneak out again
late at night.
But first, theyâve got to get past Neville Longbottom, who insists that heâll fight them before he lets them break the rules yet again.
All of this conflict is
âgood guysâ against âother good guys.â And it makes the story stronger.
It makes the battle against the âbad guysâ that much harder.
After the dust has
settled, the school headmaster, Albus Dumbledore awards points to Harry,
Ron, and Hermione, for their courage and wits in battling Voldemort.
And he also awards points
to Neville Longbottom. Why? Neville didnât do anything to fight
Voldemort. But as Dumbledore points out, itâs just as hard to stand up
to your friends as your enemies. (In my own experience, itâs sometimes
harder to stand up to your friends. Peer pressure and all that.) Itâs
the first courageous thing Neville has ever done, but it wonât be the
last. In standing up to his friends, Neville has become a better person.
So have Harry, Ron, and Hermione.
The main story in the
Harry Potter series is consistently the âgood guysâ against the âbad
guys.â Thatâs the way it should be in this series. But the story is made
so much better by the many, many ways in which the âgood guysâ are
infighting with the other âgood guys.â
Homework
- Is your story a âgood guysâ versus âbad guysâ kind of story?
- How many conflicts do you have between âgood guysâ and other âgood guys?â
- Can you add more?
- Will that make it a better story?
About The Author
Randy Ingermanson
is a theoretical physicist and the award-winning author of six novels.
He has taught at numerous writing conferences over the years and
publishes the free monthly Advanced Fiction Writing E-zine.